AI & Technology

Redefining the known: What does a high performer look like in the age of AI?

By Helen Bonar, Senior Manager - HR at Insight explores key aspects of high performance in the era of AI and what this means for HR leaders

The definition of a high performer, as we know, has changed.  

As AI continues changing the way we approach sourcing information and applying skills, knowledge within the workplace is becoming a smaller piece of a much bigger puzzle. Now, distinguishing yourself from your colleagues is about how effectively you can combine what you know with the AI tools available to contribute to the wider business.  

It’s important to note that high performers won’t necessarily be those using AI the most, but those thinking carefully about how it’s used in the moments that matter most. They don’t treat it as a default. Instead, what sets them apart is their ability to see where AI adds value and puts it to work with sound judgement.  

Here’s what a high performer looks like in practice in the era of AI.  

Spotting a high performer: look at their thinking 

First of all, they’ll be curious. They’ll test out new technology, read up on the latest developments and explore ways to challenge the status quo with AI to find new opportunities or solve a problem. In this growth mindset, they’ll treat AI as a toolkit that they repeatedly check rather than something to review once and leave well alone.  

But they won’t be curious in isolation. They’ll think critically and strategically too. After all, using AI for the sake of it does little to add value without a strong foundation of context and guidance. High performers understand AI can solve an issue, support an organisational priority and where it’s better left out of the equation altogether. 

This becomes more important as AI shifts from carrying out administrative tasks to informing real business decisions. What might seem like an authoritative output could actually be riddled with inaccuracies and bias. Failing to critically evaluate can result in damaged customer relationships, financial losses or delayed projects.  

The responsibility of work can’t be outsourced to AI. Even when a decision is informed by it, the final buck for any outcomes sits with the individual and their organisation. Delivering work with AI that’s not underpinned by concrete judgement isn’t high performance; it’s a potential problem.  

Moving beyond the individual 

Traditionally, high performance has been looked at through a lens of individual actions and achievements. For example, the targets a person has met or the accreditation they’ve secured. But, in an AI-driven organisation, this definition is changing.   

Now, adding value is about looking beyond your own to-do list. High performers who use AI to effectively enhance their own work may look further afield to those around them. In doing so, they look to share the tips, tricks and lessons they’ve learnt to help others build the confidence and knowledge to experiment. This means AI expertise doesn’t sit in isolated pockets of individual investigation into collective investigation.  

With organisations investing in AI, there’s a risk that inherent human skills are treated as secondary. In reality, skills like empathy, communication and emotional intelligence will become more crucial as technology plays a bigger role in our lives.  

This is where humans come into their element. AI can’t take on the responsibility of building trust, navigating complex stakeholder relationships or applying nuance to difficult organisation-specific decisions. These moments require an understanding of others and the wider envrionment. 

Against a backdrop of changing workplace and employee expectations, this will become even more important. Whilst some individuals will be positive about what AI offers, others may be concerned about what it means for their role and responsibilities. High performers recognise these concerns. In response, they can be seen creating time and space for conversations. They act as a person to turn to for guidance through change. As AI adoption increases, these individuals will be essential for bridging the context and trust gap for others who are uncertain.  

The HR leader experience  

This shift means that HR Leaders need to reconsider how they attract, develop and retain top talent. For the recruitment process, a greater emphasis needs to be placed on these characteristics. Experience will of course remain important, but an individual’s ability to showcase these skills may provide a good indication of future potential. Interviews and tasks can be tailored to evaluate these areas through practical scenarios or problem-solving assessments.  

Ultimately, AI adoption only creates value when it translates into better outcomes. That can mean sharper prioritisation, stronger business performance, quicker decision-making or improved customer experience. High performers will be connecting AI back to the objectives that matter to them and the business, instead of treating it as just a standalone productivity tool. 

In tandem with this, HR leaders need to update job descriptions, progression conversations, talent planning and performance frameworks to meet the qualities needed for an AI-powered work environment. 

For example, reward and recognition systems need to be considered. If an employee is incentivised to look beyond their own output towards others, they’re more likely to participate in knowledge sharing.  

In the same vein, learning and development can’t be limited to one-off training sessions on particular tools and topics. Organisations need to use training as an opportunity to help employees continually learn, reflect and work with others.  However, this training must be built on a basis of clear expectations and boundaries around safe AI usage.  

In practice, this could look like an AI talent development programme that takes employees through a structured, gamified learning journey that combines practical tools like Copilot and internal LLMs with microlearning and hands-on challenges. Rather than treating AI training as a one-time event, this approach creates a visible progression path from beginner to expert, with employees able to advance through the different levels by practicing their skills, tackling challenges, educating peers and developing their own AI solutions.   

Managers will also play a critical role in bringing this definition of high performance to life. It’s not enough to encourage employees to experiment with AI; leaders need to be clear on what good judgement looks like, how AI should support quality work, and where human accountability sits. 

As a result, responsible AI use needs to be part of performance conversations now. During these conversations, high performers will be those who understand the importance of validating outputs, protecting confidential information, recognising bias, and knowing when not to use AI. The ability to pause, question and apply human judgement will become just as important as the ability to prompt effectively. 

At the same time, organisations need to recognise that AI confidence won’t necessarily develop evenly across the entire workforce. Some will gravitate to adopting new tools quickly, whilst others will need more reassurance and practical support to build confidence. Creating a culture where employees feel they can share what they’ve learned, and experiment safely can help to prevent AI knowledge from gathering in silos.  

To make this a reality, HR leaders need to secure buy-in from other senior leaders and other key business functions. By collaborating to model the characteristics and capabilities they expect from high performing employees, they set a clear example across the entire organisation.  

Conditions for high performance  

AI isn’t making our human capabilities less valuable. It’s simply changing which matter most within the workplace. Tomorrow’s high performers will combine the expertise of their role and AI know-how with curiosity, critical thinking, a collaborative attitude, and strong communication skills.  

Fundamentally, AI transformation is not only a technology shift; it is a people, leadership and culture shift. The organisations that thrive will be those that create the conditions for employees to use AI with curiosity, confidence, and care — while staying anchored in human judgement, accountability, and business impact. 

Related Articles

Back to top button