AI-generated influencer content is struggling to match the engagement achieved by human creators in Britain, according to new research that raises questions about brands’ growing reliance on artificial intelligence.
A major study by influencer marketing platform Kolsquare found that AI-tagged organic TikTok posts attracted significantly less engagement than traditional content across key European markets, including the UK, with declines ranging from 17% to 24%.
The research, which analysed 87,362 AI-tagged posts from more than 20,000 creators worldwide, compared AI content with non-AI posts published by the same influencers between October 2025 and September 2026.
The findings suggest that while brands are increasingly embracing artificial intelligence to produce content more quickly and cheaply, audiences may be less willing to engage with it.
Across the global sample, AI-tagged organic posts generated 5.5% less engagement, with the gap widening to 21.2% on TikTok. Instagram showed a much smaller difference of just 1%.
Quentin Bordage, Founder and CEO of Kolsquare, says: “Influence works because a real person has built an engaged community over time and those people trust in their authenticity. An avatar can copy the look and the tone, but it has never lived what it recommends. Take the person away, and you’re left with advertising.”
The findings come as British brands and agencies increasingly integrate AI into their influencer marketing strategies.
Kolsquare’s wider research shows that 84% of influencer marketers and 72% of creators surveyed use AI or automation tools, from campaign planning and audience analysis to scripting and video editing.
However, the commercial benefits remain uncertain.
A Bain survey cited in Kolsquare’s new report, Beyond the Hype: AI for Influencer Marketing, found that although 95% of organisations surveyed use AI, only 6% say it delivers substantial results.
Meanwhile, consumers are becoming increasingly sceptical about synthetic content.
Research from Canva and DoubleVerify, highlighted in the report, found that 78% of consumers prefer advertising created by humans, while 42% say poor-quality AI advertising damages their opinion of a brand.
More than half admit they cannot consistently identify AI-generated content, creating further challenges for marketers seeking to maintain consumer trust.
Yet the research suggests AI’s greatest value may lie behind the scenes rather than in replacing creators.
In one experiment, influencer marketing agency BeInfluence compared creators selected by AI with those chosen by its human team.
The AI favoured two larger influencers to achieve the required reach, while the agency’s team selected smaller creators who collectively delivered comparable reach, connected with different audiences and generated higher engagement.
The experiment highlights the limitations of relying entirely on algorithms, which can assess follower numbers and engagement statistics but struggle to judge personality, credibility and the strength of a creator’s relationship with their audience.
Nevertheless, AI is already delivering substantial productivity improvements.
BeInfluence previously spent 90% of its campaign analysis time gathering data and just 10% interpreting it. After integrating Kolsquare’s AI-connected tools, the agency reduced data extraction to 30%, freeing up considerably more time for strategic thinking.
For British brands, the report also highlights a significant shift in how consumers research products.
According to McKinsey research cited by Kolsquare, 38% of consumers surveyed across the UK, France and Germany now use AI to research products or make purchasing decisions.
Of those consumers, 63% use the technology to compare brands, prices and reviews, suggesting that influencer content could increasingly shape recommendations generated by AI search tools.
Detailed product reviews and demonstrations may therefore become more commercially valuable than short, attention-grabbing videos.
Research cited in the report found that 60% of YouTube videos referenced by AI in US consumer goods and automotive searches came from creators, suggesting authentic influencer content could continue influencing purchasing decisions long after a campaign ends.
The findings also raise questions about transparency in the UK influencer marketing industry.
Unlike the EU, which has introduced specific AI deepfake disclosure requirements, Britain currently has no equivalent blanket legal requirement to label AI-generated content.
However, misleading AI advertising remains subject to existing UK advertising and consumer protection laws, meaning brands must consider how synthetic content could affect consumer trust.
Kolsquare has responded by publishing an AI Manifesto, pledging not to develop technology that clones real creators or promotes virtual influencers, even where that means turning down potentially lucrative business.
Bordage believes the industry must resist the temptation to prioritise automation over authenticity. “There’s a lot of AI washing in our industry, but underneath it, this is a real revolution,” he says. In a few months, the way brands select creators, brief them and measure what they deliver has changed more than in the previous five years.”
With 59% of organisations surveyed planning to increase investment in long-term creator partnerships, the report suggests that community loyalty and genuine relationships are becoming increasingly important.
For British brands, the message is that AI can help streamline campaigns, analyse performance and identify opportunities, but human judgement remains essential.
And for influencers worried about being replaced by artificial intelligence, the findings offer some reassurance: in an increasingly synthetic world, authenticity may become their greatest commercial advantage.
About Kolsquare
Kolsquare is a Global Influencer Marketing Intelligence platform helping brands and agencies build, manage, measure and scale influencer marketing strategies with data-driven insights.
Combining advanced data analytics, AI and machine learning technologies, Kolsquare enables marketing teams to discover the right creators, understand their audiences, manage campaigns from end to end, measure impact and benchmark performance against industry standards.
Trusted by more than 2,000 global and national brands and agencies, Kolsquare provides access to one of the world’s most comprehensive creator intelligence databases, covering millions of creators across 180 countries and major social platforms including Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Snapchat and Twitch.
As a Certified B Corporation, Kolsquare is committed to advancing Responsible Influence by promoting transparency, ethical collaborations and more sustainable practices across the creator economy.
In October 2024, Kolsquare joined team.blue, one of Europe’s largest private technology groups and a leading digital enabler for businesses and entrepreneurs. team.blue brings together more than 60 brands across web hosting, domains, e-commerce, online compliance, lead generation, application solutions and social media.



