AI & Technology

The race for AI is on, but merchants want trust

There’s no escaping AI in payments, take a look at any conference agenda, the latest product launches or the latest funding round update and you’re more than likely to spot the acronym. Capital is also pouring into AI at a pace the Bank of England describes as a financial stability risk in its own right, with valuations in the sector looking, in its words, stretched. But there is an important question that could be getting lost in all the noise: what do merchants actually want?

We asked 500 UK SME decision-makers as part of our 2026 research, and their answer was remarkably straightforward. They aren’t seeking the latest innovation in AI they just want to be able to trust it.

The merchant’s perspective

More than half of the merchants we surveyed (51.8%) put security above everything else – including new technology, lower fees, and definitely above AI. This is not a minor preference buried somewhere in the data but a majority pointing to a disconnect between where the industry is directing its attention and what merchants actually value.

Merchants believe payment security is their customers’ single biggest priority at the checkout (48.6%), followed by simplicity (42.2%). Technology capability ranks lower, with 39.2% putting it first. That tells that the businesses dealing with payments every day simply want their transactions to be secure, straightforward and dependable. They want their customers to be able to complete purchases and for their businesses to remain protected.

That does not make AI the wrong investment, it’s just a signal that the industry should be careful about assuming that the technology that is attracting the most attention is automatically the technology merchants want the most.

Who is picking up the tab?

All of this investment has a cost – the underlying resources are expensive; data centres need energy, AI needs computing power and infrastructure needs capital. In payments those costs do not disappear but are recovered, eventually, by fees.

For merchants this is a pressure point, with 16.2% of those we surveyed saying fees are too high. Among the smallest businesses, that rises to 27.2% yet these are the companies least likely to have spare margin to accommodate costs generated by investment decisions they did not ask for in the first place. Asking a micro-merchant to help carry the cost of an infrastructure boom they never voted for in return for capability they don’t want can be a difficult proposition to defend.

The other side has AI too

While AI is doing much to improve payments, some of those same capabilities are concurrently being used to make fraud more sophisticated. Generative AI, for example, has lowered the barriers for criminals, with deepfake fraud attempts rising by 94% in the UK, and AI-related fraud has climbed from under a quarter of cases to more than a third in the space of a year. Fraudsters can produce convincing phishing messages, replicate someone’s voice from just a few seconds of recorded audio or create synthetic identities at scale. Once these techniques required specialist skills but that’s not the case anymore, as they can be accessed and deployed with very little friction.

Merchants understand this as a growing threat, with a quarter (25.2%) expecting fraud and financial crime to get worse over the next three years. Those concerns aren’t irrational when the industry is investing in technology that can strengthen its defences while simultaneously giving attackers a more powerful toolkit.

Trust is the product

None of this is an argument against technology, and it certainly is not an argument for slowing innovation. AI will have an increasingly important role in payments, whether that is identifying fraud, automating reconciliation or helping merchants extract more value from the transaction data they already generate. Pointed at a defined problem, it earns its place.

The payments industry is understandably focused on what the future might look like, but the merchants we surveyed are asking for something more grounded, and frankly more useful. A provider that treats their trust as the product, not the afterthought.

Related Articles

Back to top button