If you’ve browsed the internet for any amount of time over the last week, it’s likely you’ve come across CAPTCHAs. Standing for ‘Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart’ these are security measures designed to differentiate between human users and automated bots, and ultimately protect the website from malicious attacks.
At one point in time, even traditional CAPTCHAs were effective in their job. But as the years have progressed – and cyber attacking technology along with them – their effectiveness has lessened. Now, in 2024, the landscape of CAPTCHA technology has changed. So are they still the best method of cybersecurity against bots?
Traditional CAPTCHA: Explained
To understand how the world of CAPTCHAs has changed, it’s first important to understand what traditional CAPTCHAs are. In 2024, these are the most basic forms of CAPTCHAs – typically involving a challenge presented to users that requires human cognitive abilities to solve. These challenges are designed to be difficult for automated systems, but easy for humans.
A text-based CAPTCHA, for instance, involves the user being presented with a distorted or obscured image of alphanumeric characters. An image-based CAPTCHA will ask the user to select images that meet a certain criteria – for instance, selecting all the images that contain traffic lights – from a grid of photos. A question-based CAPTCHA will ask a simple question, such as: ‘what is 2 + 4?’
The Problem With Traditional CAPTCHAs
To manage bots in 2024, however, these kinds of CAPTCHAs have arguably run their course. For one thing, many companies aren’t implementing them at all due to their potential to frustrate users. In a study undertaken in 2022, it was discovered that as many as 30% of users will abandon a task if they have to fill out a CAPTCHA, leading to a strong chance of a massive bounce rate for companies, which will simultaneously negatively affect their SEO ratings.
Even more importantly, as technology has evolved, bots have evolved along with it. In recent years, bots have become far more sophisticated and capable of executing complex tasks. AI and ML have a lot to answer for here. In 2024, modern bots will leverage AI and ML algorithms to learn from data and continuously improve their performance, enabling them to analyse and adapt to various CAPTCHA challenges.
Many are also equipped with NLP capabilities, giving them the ability to understand and generate human-like text, which allows them to engage in conversations or generate content that appears authentic. Behavioural mimicry has also been achieved through ‘advanced automation’. Many bots now use headless browser technology that allows them to interact with web pages just as a human user would, mimicking mouse movements, scrolls, timing patterns, and learning from their interactions with CAPTCHAs to adapt their strategies. Let’s look a little more specifically at the traditional CAPTCHA solutions mentioned earlier:
- Text-Based CAPTCHA
Bots can now utilise OCR – optical character recognition – to decipher and solve distorted text.
- Image-Based CAPTCHA
For image-based CAPTCHAs, AI algorithms can now analyse and classify images, allowing bots to identify and select the correct options without any human intervention.
- Question-Based CAPTCHA
Through NLP, advanced bots can analyse and interpret questions, understanding variations in wording and context to generate the correct answer.
Advanced CAPTCHAs for Advanced Bots
It’s fair to say that traditional CAPTCHAs, as described above, are not good enough to fight in the modern bot battleground – but that doesn’t mean CAPTCHAs as a concept are obsolete. On the contrary, over the last few years, advanced CAPTCHAs have been developed to manage bot traffic and stop them from bypassing the system. These CAPTCHAs go beyond simple text or question-based challenges. They are invisible precautions that use technologies like AI, ML, and behavioural analysis to both enhance their security and solve the problem of frustrated users.
One of the most effective things about them is that – rather than asking you to answer a question or recognise text – they will work quietly in the background, assessing mouse movements, scrolling patterns, and time spent on a page to determine if there is any suspicious activity. This then makes it far more difficult for bots to determine what action to take, and with advanced CAPTCHA systems also employing ML algorithms to continuously improve their detection mechanisms, they will only get better at catching them as time moves on.
Conclusion
As well as advanced CAPTCHAs, many organisations around the world are implementing numerous bot management solutions, recognising how damaging they can be and working to be proactive rather than reactive in their response to them. As mentioned before, however, not everyone is protected yet. In order to truly fight the bot problem, it’s important to understand exactly what they’re trying to accomplish, and disregard any cybersecurity solutions – such as traditional CAPTCHAs – that are outdated. That’s the only way the fight can be won now and in the future.
Balla
